Restoring urban life by tearing down freeways

Demolition of the Perimetral highway in Rio de Janeiro, April 20 2014. Photo by Ricardo Moraes, Reuters

Full text by for BID Blogs

This week the Municipality of Rio de Janeiro finished the demolition of an elevated highway that ran through the port area and was considered one of the city’s vital arteries.  This was part of a project to revitalize the area, making it a more pleasant environment, particularly for pedestrians.  This action is not unique.  Demolishing old structures, which has been built for the automobile without concern for the cityscape around it, is a trend that has become more common as mayors and residents place increasing value on the quality of their cities.   Some notable examples of this trend are:

1) San Francisco:

In 1991 the Embarcadero Freeway, a double decker viaduct on the San Francisco waterfront was finally demolished, following a lively debate on whether its removal would cause severe traffic problems.  After the 1989 earthquake damaged it, the debate was quickly solved since the freeway was closed without significant traffic problems.  The result today is a beautiful walkway between the Ferry Building and the Fisherman’s Warf, a major destination for both visitors and residents alike.

El Embarcadero de San Francisco en 1974. Foto "The Horror" de James Aaron Dillon.

El edificio del Ferry hoy. Foto de Eric Hunt.

San Francisco antes y después

2) Seoul: 

The  Cheonggyecheon park in downtown Seoul is another example of an urban restoration project that required tearing down a major freeway.  During the post war period, the Cheonggyechon River was covered with concrete and later an elevated highway was built on top of it.   Beginning in 2003 the city decided to remove the highway and create a riverfront urban space, which in turn was the catalyst for the revitalization of the downtown area.  It has been a great success for the pleasant atmosphere it created, for its positive environmental impacts, and for increasing the value of properties in its surrounding areas.  It earned the city a reputation of bold action in the face of pressures to maintain the status quo, especially for the defenders of ambitious transit projects.

La ribera del río Cheonggyecheon hoy

La ribera del río es hoy un espacio de animación y confluencia

Seúl antes y después

Cheonggyecheon

The  IDB has supported a number of revitalization projects that placed primary emphasis in transforming the urban landscape into lively urban spaces, where people can congregate and interact.  Examples include the “Orla Morena” project in Campo Grande, Brazil, the Quito Historic Center revitalization project, in Ecuador and the Roosevelt plaza (part of the PROCENTRO project in São Paulo).  A common characteristic of these projects was the reduction of vehicular traffic to make space for pedestrian streets and bicycle lanes. Despite initial reactions by either merchants or motorists, traffic problems in general have been minimized, either by discouraging vehicles from using central areas and/or by significantly improving public transportation.

The trend is clear:  the automobile has to make room for people in cities.  No matter how necessary the urban freeways may seem, there are always alternatives.

Advertisements

2 comments

  1. This topic is so current for me. In Toronto, debate is still raging on as to whether the city should or shouldn’t tear down the Gardner Expressway. I think if would be one of the best ideas, but then council is citing traffic conditions in the city would worsen. I feel if the highway served its purpose in its heyday, then it’s time to move on and allow progress to take over. I especially like the idea of seen a green zone set up for that space where parks would dominate the city’s skyline!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s